Firms Use Earnings Guidance to Mitigate Complexity of ESG Disclosures
Companies in the United States are turning to voluntary earnings guidance to prevent confusion resulting from environmental, social and governance disclosures, according to a new study from researchers at Florida Atlantic University and the University of Vassa in Finland.
Companies in the United States are turning to voluntary earnings guidance to prevent confusion resulting from environmental, social and governance disclosures, according to a new study from researchers at Florida Atlantic University and the University of Vaasa in Finland.
The paper sheds new light on how environmental, social and governance disclosures from companies may increase information asymmetry, challenging previous theories that ESG disclosures enhanced transparency.
Information asymmetry happens when investors have less access to critical information about a firm, often causing confusion and inefficiencies in the market. Reducing this lack of information is crucial for investors to make sound decision-making. To combat this, firms are releasing voluntary earnings guidance, or disclosures on estimates about future financial earnings, to help reduce speculation amongst investors.
“There is a belief that ESG disclosures would decrease or improve the information asymmetry. However, because of the different ways companies use ESG disclosure, it may create confusion among market participants,” said Anna Agapova, Ph.D., associate professor of finance in FAU’s College of Business. “What we find is that companies increase issuing voluntary earnings guidance to mitigate the unexpected effect of ESG disclosure on information asymmetry.”
The paper, “Navigating Transparency: The Interplay of ESG Disclosure and Voluntary Earnings Guidance,” was accepted for publication in the International Review of Financial Analysis in the winter.
Researchers analyzed data from publicly listed U.S. companies from 2002-21, relying on 54,878 firm-quarter observations. Researchers measured information asymmetry with four proxies: bid-ask spread, Amihud illiquidity measure, distribution of analysts’ forecasts, and standard deviation of earnings announcements’ returns.
Despite the voluntary earnings guidance mitigating possible confusion with ESG disclosures, researchers found that market participants did not have a clear understanding of how to interpret ESG disclosures alongside the earnings guidance.
“The conclusions in this paper add to the debate regarding the need for clear and formalized guidelines for sustainability reporting and disclosure through the establishment of proper standards for sustainability that should help decrease disagreement and improve a common understanding regarding ESG information,” authors noted in the study.
Study co-authors are Tatiana King, Ph.D., associate professor in the University of Vaasa’s school of accounting and finance; and Mikko Ranta, Ph.D., associate professor of accounting at the University of Vaasa.
-FAU-
Latest Research
- FAU Experts for the 2025 Atlantic Hurricane SeasonSeveral Florida Atlantic University faculty experts are available to discuss a range of hurricane-related topics such as preparedness, evacuation planning, storm impacts and post-disaster recovery.
- FAU Engineering Lands NSF Grant for Multi-robot Coordination TestbedThe project will tackle some of the most challenging problems in autonomous systems by enabling robust, scalable coordination of aerial robot teams in unpredictable real-world environments.
- 'Sharkitecture:' A Nanoscale Look Inside a Blacktip Shark's SkeletonFAU researchers have mapped the internal structure of blacktip sharks in unprecedented detail using synchrotron X-ray nanotomography with detailed 3D imaging and in-situ mechanical testing.
- Hari Kalva, Ph.D., Inducted into the Florida Inventors Hall of FameWith 73 U.S. patents to his name, FAU engineering's Hari Kalva, Ph.D., a pioneering innovator in video technology, is one of 10 inventors selected for the 2025 class of the Florida Inventors Hall of Fame.
- Study: Supply Chain Plasticity and Firm Adaptation to Tariffs, RiskAs tariffs create economic uncertainty for firms and consumers , supply chain plasticity could be the key to helping firms navigate the trade environment, according to researchers at FAU and two other schools.
- Cyberbullying in Any Form Can Be Traumatizing for KidsA national FAU study finds even subtle online bullying - like exclusion from group chats - is linked to PTSD symptoms, suggesting that cyberbullying should be classified as an adverse childhood experience.