A polarizing debate: Florida’s controversial permitless carry law
Since HB 543 took effect on July 1, there has been considerable uncertainty surrounding the implications of the new permitless gun carry law in Florida. Although the new law doesn’t change who can purchase a firearm, what firearms can be carried or the three-day waiting period, Floridians have divergent views on what public safety should look like moving forward.
Governor Ron DeSantis signed HB 543 into law in April, making Florida the 26th state not to require a concealed weapons license.
“Concealed carry” refers to the legal possession of a hidden firearm. Before the passing of HB 543, Floridians needed a concealed weapon permit to carry a hidden firearm, with limited exceptions. After July 1, anyone who legally owns a gun may carry it concealed without a license. However, firearms are still prohibited in public places such as schools, courthouses, airports and some private businesses.
A recent poll by the University of North Florida’s Public Opinion Research Lab shows that three-quarters of Floridians oppose the law. Even gun owners in Florida are worried the new law will pose unsafe conditions.
Melba V. Pearson, director of the Prosecutorial Policy Program at Florida International University, believes as a gun owner and lawyer that permitless carry is concerning for multiple reasons: fewer background checks, less training and misunderstandings of where to carry a gun.
“It eliminates the additional background check that was required to receive a concealed weapons permit, as well as ends the requirement to take a concealed weapons class. Not everyone is on top of the changes in the law when it comes to firearms, including where one can carry and where they cannot. It also impacts law enforcement in terms of it being permissible for more people to carry weapons – potentially making encounters more dangerous,” said Pearson.
Scientific evidence suggests that removing concealed carry permitting systems is associated with higher rates of gun homicide and violent crime. A 2022 study by GVPedia analyzed CDC data from states with permitless carry laws.
It concluded that states that passed a permitless carry law suffered from a 22% increase in gun homicide for the three years after the law’s passage. Also, it found out that from the 65 national-level academic studies, 66% find that weakening concealed carry laws increases crime, and only five studies since 2005 show a decrease in crime.
“At a time when gun violence is already rampant, Florida’s permitless carry law will make people less safe and put law enforcement in danger. Data shows permitless carry laws like the one recently enacted in Florida are directly associated with an increase in violent crime and gun homicides,” said Colin Seeberger, senior advisor for Communications with the Center for American Progress.
According to the nonprofit organization EveryTown for Gun Safety, more than 7,000 Floridians are shot and killed or wounded in an average year. Guns are the second-leading cause of death among children and teens in Florida. Likewise, a study conducted by researchers at Florida Atlantic University’s Schmidt College of Medicine concluded that from 1999 to 2017, 38,942 firearm-related deaths occurred in 5 to 18-year-olds.
Nonetheless, gun buying spiked nationwide during the pandemic, and it’s holding steady. Pandemic gun sales raised the share of Americans living in armed homes to 46%, up from 32% in 2010. According to the National Shooting Sports Foundation, nearly 30% of the 18.5 million firearms purchased in the United States in 2021 went to first-time gun owners.
Managing Director of Public Affairs of the Firearm Industry Trade Association Mark Oliva believes the spike is typical during election years.
“We saw over $21.5 million background checks for the sale of a firearm in 2020. That’s the most ever recorded. The most recent spike, though, was a combination of factors. Certainly, crime and concerns for personal safety were top reasons for people buying firearms, especially at such an increased pace,” said Oliva. “…Self-protection was the primary reason that was given to our retailers when they were selling firearms during this surge of gun purchases. That continues through today. Also, it was an election year. We typically see background checks for firearm sales rise during election years as campaign trail rhetoric around gun rights causes some to buy the firearm of their choosing before that right is robbed of them.”
A 2019 Gallup survey concluded that roughly 63% of gun owners were most likely to cite personal safety or protection as why they had a firearm. Additionally, according to the Bureau of Justice Statistics, criminals who had firearms while committing crimes acquired the weapons through illegal means in 90% of the cases.
The result of this is the ongoing gun debate has once again taken center stage, set against the backdrop of escalating political polarization and the approach of an upcoming general election year. As of today, there is a notable absence of statistical data regarding the impacts of Florida’s new permitless carry law in the last two months.
Sofia De La Espriella is the News Editor for the University Press. Email sdelaespriel2022@fau.edu or message her on Instagram @sofidelaespriella for information regarding this or other stories.
Latest University Press
- A new era in Paradise: FAU’s new football head coach Zach Kittley at his inaugural press conference“Welcome to paradise, Coach Kittley.” Those were the five words FAU football’s newest head coach, Zach Kittley, kept hearing after the university announced his new role on Dec. 3. On Dec. 6, at his inaugural press conference at the Schmidt Complex Owls Perch, a teary-eyed Kittley spoke in front of his family, former FAU players,...
- FAU’s safety net for homeless and former foster care youth studentsOf over 30,000 students at Florida Atlantic University, there are 53 homeless and 125 former foster youth students this fall, according to university records. FAU provides a “safety net” of advocacy resources for all students but can be invaluable for this demographic, who have been dealt a challenging stack of cards. Verified homeless or former...
- The Sharks swim to paradise: FAU entrepreneurs pitch to ABC’s ‘Shark Tank’ judgesOn Wednesday, Florida Atlantic University welcomed three of the judges from ABC’s hit TV show, “Shark Tank.” Kevin O’Leary, Daymond John and Robert Herjavec hit the stage at FAU’s Carole and Barry Kaye Performing Arts Auditorium for the first-ever recreation of the show, known as the “CrocTank.” Similar to the show, the Croc Tank allowed...
- Women’s Basketball: The Lady Owls ‘feast’ on success after an eventful Thanksgiving ClassicFlorida Atlantic (5-3) returned to paradise to host their annual Thanksgiving Classic from Nov.29 to Dec.1. They welcomed the Manhattan Jaspers (5-2) and Austin Peay Governors (3-4) to the Elly. The three-day event didn’t have a trophy to be won, but each team played for an opportunity to better themselves for future games to come. ...
- Indo-Grooving through paradise: FAU’s first Bollywood fusion dance team on the Boca Raton campusIndo Grooves is Florida Atlantic University’s first Bollywood fusion dance team on the Boca Raton campus. Through celebrating traditional Indian events and bringing together students through dance, they aim to unite students of all cultural backgrounds. With a little under 50% of the international student population being of Indian heritage, providing a space for these...
- ‘It went nowhere’: FAU Faculty Senate echoes concerns about presidential search criteriaAs the fall 2024 semester comes to a close, the Florida Atlantic University Faculty Senate held its final meeting on Monday, Dec. 2. The senators discussed the presidential search, academic freedom and student enrollment. The Presidential Search Faculty Senate President Kimberly Dunn started off the meeting with an update about the presidential search. At the last...